Bitget App
Trade smarter
Buy cryptoMarketsTradeFuturesEarnAISquareMore
Supreme Court will hear Apple’s appeal in Epic Games App Store fight

Supreme Court will hear Apple’s appeal in Epic Games App Store fight

CryptopolitanCryptopolitan2026/07/02 00:14
By:Cryptopolitan

The U.S. Supreme Court agreed on Tuesday to listen to Apple’s appeal to a contempt ruling in its years-long antitrust battle with Epic Games, which could set the stage for a landmark decision on how courts judge suits against tech platforms.

The case revolves around the validity of a civil contempt ruling against a company for violating the “spirit” of a court order when the order’s text does not explicitly prohibit the conduct in question.

A seven year old dispute

Epic Games sued Apple in 2020 over App Store payment restrictions, arguing that the iPhone maker’s rules blocked developers from directing users to cheaper purchasing options outside the app. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers issued an injunction in 2021 ordering Apple to allow the external payment links.

Apple responded by creating a system that permitted outside links but charged developers commissions ranging from 12% up to 27% on resulting sales. Before the dispute, Apple had taken a 30% cut of App Store transactions, a rate it reduced to 15% for many smaller developers in 2020.

Epic accused the company of “malicious compliance” and asked the court to intervene. In April 2025, Gonzalez Rogers found Apple in contempt of the original order. An appeals court largely affirmed that finding in December, though it struck down a provision that would have barred Apple from charging any commission on purchases made through external links.

What is the Supreme Court deciding on?

Apple filed a 34-page petition in May asking the Supreme Court justices to review two pertinent areas of this longstanding case. Firstly, Apple contends that a party cannot be punished for conduct that a court injunction never expressly prohibited. The company’s lawyers argued that the lower court penalized Apple for violating the order’s “spirit” rather than its explicit terms, a standard Apple says is unique to the Ninth Circuit.

Secondly, Apple questioned whether this injunction should apply to all U.S.-based developers or only to Epic. The Supreme Court declined to take up this second issue, meaning the injunction still applies for all developers for now.

When announcing the case, the court framed the central question exactly as “whether a court may hold a party in civil contempt based on a violation of an injunction’s ‘spirit’ where the injunction is silent as to the conduct upon which contempt is based.”

What’s next for the appeal lawsuit

Court sittings are expected to begin when the Supreme Court’s new term starts in October, with a ruling likely by June 2027. In the meantime, the contempt finding remains in effect after Justice Elena Kagan denied Apple’s request to pause the ruling last month.

Both sides of the dispute sounded confident that the ruling would go their way. “This is an important question of law, and we are pleased the Supreme Court will hear our case,” an Apple spokesperson stated. Epic responded on X, saying that “We’re heading to the Supreme Court, where we’ll continue our fight against junk fees Apple charges on third-party payments.”

 

 

0
0

Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.

Understand the market, then trade.
Bitget offers one-stop trading for cryptocurrencies, stocks, and gold.
Trade now!

You may also like

The "Outlier" Investment Art in the New Era of Berky

他山之石观投资2026/09/14 09:22
The "Outlier" Investment Art in the New Era of Berky

Chevron (CVX.US) explores alternative hedging for Middle East supply disruptions: targets Argentina and the Mediterranean to drive global LNG growth, seeks deal with India

Chevron is focusing on Argentina and the Mediterranean region, seeking global growth in liquefied natural gas, and plans to reach an agreement with India.

智通财经2026/09/14 09:12
Chevron (CVX.US) explores alternative hedging for Middle East supply disruptions: targets Argentina and the Mediterranean to drive global LNG growth, seeks deal with India

Energy and food price pressures intensify, potentially triggering an inflation rebound! The Bank of England may struggle to remain "calm" as market rate hike bets surge

The upward pressure on energy prices caused by the unresolved Middle East war is mounting. New risks are also approaching, which may keep inflation above the Bank of England’s 2% target for most of next year.

智通财经2026/09/14 08:57
Energy and food price pressures intensify, potentially triggering an inflation rebound! The Bank of England may struggle to remain "calm" as market rate hike bets surge

AstraZeneca (AZN.US) Breast Cancer Drug Etcamah Faces Setback in Phase III Clinical Trial, Potentially Impacting Billions in Sales

Bloomberg Intelligence analyst John Murphy stated that the setback in AstraZeneca's breast cancer drug trial could reduce sales in 2035 by $2.6 billion to $3.8 billion.

智通财经2026/09/14 08:41
AstraZeneca (AZN.US) Breast Cancer Drug Etcamah Faces Setback in Phase III Clinical Trial, Potentially Impacting Billions in Sales